VAR Penalty
In a gripping FA Cup quarter-final match between Leeds United and West Ham, an incident involving Max Kilman and Anton Stach has sparked significant controversy. During the 34th minute, Stach was injured after a collision with West Ham defender Kilman, who made a late tackle. Despite the apparent foul, the match officials, with VAR in operation, did not award a penalty, leading to widespread debate over the decision-making process.
Mark Clattenberg said: “There is no doubt in my mind that Leeds United should have been awarded a penalty kick in their exciting FA Cup match v West Ham. The challenge by Max Kilman on Anton Stach was reckless, catching his opponent on the foot without touching the ball. The only way a penalty kick could not be awarded is if the ball is out of the field of play when the challenge was made. We can see from the replay that the ball was in play. That shouldn’t matter. He’s wiped the player out. At the very least, it’s careless. But because there’s excessive force in the challenge, there are elements of recklessness. It’s beyond me that referees aren’t judging that as a foul. There’s no malice, so it’s not serious foul play, but if it’s not even seen as reckless, then it has to be careless, and therefore, a penalty. The match officials have got it wrong.”
The incident has raised questions about the consistency and effectiveness of VAR, particularly in high-stakes matches. While VAR was operational during the game, the decision not to intervene in Kilman’s tackle on Stach has been criticized. In contrast, a similar situation involving Brenden Aaronson later in the match led to a goal by Dominic Calvert-Lewin, highlighting inconsistencies in officiating.
The debate over the incident has led to calls for a review of the Professional Game Match Officials Limited (PGMOL) and their approach to training referees. The suggestion is for referees to engage in discussions and review video clips of similar challenges to improve their understanding and decision-making processes. This incident underscores the ongoing challenges faced by officials in maintaining fairness and consistency in football matches.
About The Author
