Another three wins to add to a clean sweep in the first month meant Newcastle were sitting top of the table and Keegan had won his fifth manager of the month award. He became the second manager after Joe Kinnear of Wimbledon to win this award in back to back months.
| Month | Cateogry | Name | Club | Matches Played | Matches Won | Matches Drawn | Matches Lost |
| Sep-94 | Manager of the month | Kevin Keegan | Newcastle United | 4 | 3 | 1 | 0 |
